
Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney (R) announced on Tuesday that Paul Lucia, 61, of Islip Terrace, was sentenced to 10 years in prison after pleading guilty in October 2026 to Arson in the Second Degree and other related charges. The defendant admitted to deliberately setting fire to Riley Fibbers in East Islip after being asked to leave by staff.

“What began as a simple request for the defendant to leave the premises escalated into an unwarranted and dangerous act of arson,” said District Attorney Tierney in a press release. “I am grateful to the investigators on this case for gathering the evidence necessary for my office to hold this defendant accountable.”
According to court documents and the defendant’s admissions during his guilty plea allocution, on November 20, 2025, at approximately 5:30p.m., Lucia was a patron at Riley Fibbers Pub & Restaurant in East Islip when he was asked to leave by staff after taking a picture of one of the staff members.
The defendant drove away in a white Jeep Patriot and returned at approximately 7:30p.m. with a gas can and a lighter. Video surveillance shows that Lucia exited the Jeep and dumped liquid from the gas can near the rear entrance of the restaurant. The entrance was open and occupied by patrons and employees at the time.
Shortly thereafter, flames erupted on the premises as Lucia walked back to his vehicle and threw the gas can over a fence onto the adjacent property. He then immediately drove away.
Riley Fibbers incurred fire damage to an exterior awning and the kitchen. Thankfully, no one was hurt or injured.
A witness at the scene provided a license plate number for the Jeep that Lucia was driving. Those plates were found to have been reported stolen one week prior to the arson.
Detectives with the Suffolk County Police Department’s Arson Squad conducted an investigation and recovered the cap to the gas can from a flowerpot outside the bar as well as the gas can from the adjacent property. A certified canine from the Suffolk County Fire Marshal’s Office was deployed at the scene and indicated the presence of ignitable liquids in several locations.
The following day, members of the Suffolk County Police Department located the defendant driving the white Jeep on Sunrise Highway and initiated a traffic stop. Lucia was placed under arrest, and a lighter that was used in the arson was recovered from inside the vehicle.
On October 13, 2026, Lucia pleaded guilty before Acting Supreme Court Justice Richard Horowitz to the following charges: Arson in the Second Degree, a class B violent felony; Arson in the Third Degree, a class C felony; and two counts of Criminal Possession of Stolen Property in the Fifth Degree, class A misdemeanors.
On November 17, 2026, Lucia was sentenced to 10 years in prison, to be followed by five years of post-release supervision. He is being represented by Michael Elbert, Esq.
This case was prosecuted by Assistant District Attorneys Sean Lorthioir and Jeremy Waite of the Major Crime Bureau’s Arson Unit. Members of the Arson Unit received specialized training in the investigation and prosecution of arson cases from certified Fire Investigators at the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, and New York State Division of Homeland Security and Emergency Services. The investigation was conducted by Detectives John Boreshesky and Michael Langella of the Suffolk County Police Department’s Arson Squad.












