The Fourth District includes Belle Terre, East Setauket, Gordon Heights, Old Field, Poquott, Port Jefferson, Setauket, Stony Brook, Strongs Neck, and Terryville, and parts of Centereach, Coram, Middle Island, Port Jefferson Station, and Selden.
Fourth District voters have two good candidates to represent them in Albany this year.
Rounding out her first term is Assemblywoman Rebecca Kassay, whom we did not endorse last year. The Port Jefferson Democrat, we think, is carefully navigating the brutal politics of the Albany majority, while also balancing local needs. Some big wins for her came in the form of State aid for the Mill Pond Dam, helping secure the Lawrence Aviation site in Port Jefferson Station for eventual rail electrification, and getting a bill through to increase accountability on the mobile gambling epidemic.
In one of the cheekiest moments of the last two years, Kassay and company convened on the Lawrence Aviation property in a de facto protest move against the State. When earmarking billions of dollars without a second thought, the State couldn’t be pressed to spend $10 to buy that property, much to Kassay’s – and our – confusion. At the ribbon-cutting, she held up two $5 bills – a great display of how Albany will spend itself into eternal debt, but won’t take money literally being handed to them.
Kassay faces first-time candidate Will Sussman. At the age of just 27, the Port Jefferson Republican has had a storied career thus far: earning a professorship at Yeshiva University, testifying before Congress on anti-semitism, and rotating around various policy think tanks.
Sussman and Kassay both rightly say the budget process is practically unworkable. It’s already backwards from the start and results in poison pills required to force waffling members into checkmate.
Sussman’s solution? Don’t vote for any budgets, especially those that bail out New York City.
Kassay’s record? Vote for the bills that bring money to Suffolk, even at the risk of giving herself a black eye by cosigning an unpopular bill that she wasn’t able to draft.
Sussman critiques Kassay on that, but doesn’t recognize that Kassay is in the classic damned-if-you, damned-if-you-don’t position. On that dynamic, Kassay told us, “maybe that’s exactly where I’m supposed to be because I represent a purple district.”
Sussman took umbrage with Kassay’s participation of a bill that he says would have left the door ajar for the DOT to seize parts of the Setauket-Port Jefferson Station Greenway trail for a potential bypass. Kassay, along with Republican Senator Anthony Palumbo and Republican County Executive Ed Romaine, were part of the effort to rectify it and secure its conservation in perpetuity.
Sussman says it was a last-minute move to cover a mistake. Perhaps, but it was rectified in the end, and the reality is, there’s no way the residents would have ever allowed Kassay and company to see re-election had their Greenway been paved over.
Finally, in the eleventh hour of the campaign, Sussman alleged Kassay engaged in a pay-to-play with a non-profit. It’s definitely a jarring, last-minute revelation, but it seems, right now, that the onus is on the non-profit, who definitely screwed up. Whether that was coordinated by Kassay is not proven and a startling allegation, even for how unnecessarily negative this campaign has been. Kassay is entitled to her day in court, should the Attorney General investigate.
Sussman is sharp and wants to hold the majority accountable. Kassay is pragmatic and plays nicely in the sandbox surrounded by Republicans in Suffolk. We urge her to keep up the cudgel against the majority as she gains more seniority should she be re-elected. We also urge Sussman to continue getting involved in local politics and civics. We think he has a promising future.
The Messenger endorses Kassay.












