Nick LaLota for U.S. House, NY-01

NY-01 contains the entire towns of East Hampton, Riverhead, Shelter Island, Smithtown, and Southampton, and most of Huntington. Within the Town of Brookhaven, NY-01 contains Center Moriches, Centereach, Coram, East Moriches, East Shoreham, Gordon Heights, Lake Grove, Lake Ronkonkoma, Manorville, Middle Island, Miller Place, Moriches, Mt. Sinai, Old Field, Poquott, Port Jefferson, Port Jefferson Station, Ridge, Rocky Point, Selden, Setauket, Shoreham, Sound Beach, Stony Brook, Terryville, Upton, and Wading River, with parts of Farmingville, Holbrook, Holtsville, Medford, and Yaphank. 

Congressman Nick LaLota is rounding out his second term in the U.S. House representing the lion’s share of Suffolk County. 

His first term was spent under the Biden Administration in a closely-divided, yet Republican-held House. His second term has been spent under the Trump Trifecta in an even closer-divided, yet still Republican-held House. 

That says LaLota has gotten a good look at how things work in difficult circumstances, yet has still been able to deliver tens of millions of dollars back to Suffolk, primarily for public safety, capital projects, and infrastructure. For Smithtown, that’s looked like sewers and wastewater solutions for downtown Smithtown and St. James, a new outflow pipe in Kings Park, and new police cruisers for Head of the Harbor. 

For Brookhaven, it’s looked like much-needed funds for flood mitigation in Miller Place and Sound Beach, the extension of the public water main in Calverton, and resurfacing of Harbor Road where the Mill Pond Dam once stood in Stony Brook. 

At-large, his work has consisted of police vehicles for the SCPD and Sheriff’s Offices, along with funds for a new control tower at Gabreski Airport. 

LaLota, a Republican of Amityville, has also proven his worth in working with pragmatic Democrats, such as Joe Courtney (D-CT) on Long Island Sound issues, and with Pat Ryan (D-NY) on Veterans’ issues. LaLota, a Navy Veteran himself, has made sure his office is top-tier for Veterans’ services, and has even helped secure these Veterans well-deserved war decorations. He’s also called for further attention in liver fluke cancer, which particularly affects Vietnam Veterans. 

But perhaps LaLota’s biggest claim to fame this year was that of quadrupling the SALT cap.

LaLota faces first-time candidate Chris Gallant, an Amity Harbor Democrat. Gallant’s record of service is noteworthy and laudable, as he piloted a Black Hawk helicopter and then went on to become an air traffic controller. 

However, as we’ve seen his visits to various meet-the-candidate nights, it seems to us he’s more of the generic Democrat that Suffolk puts up. He’s not well-acquainted on many issues and his comments on the SALT being only for the wealthy makes him seem out-of-touch with the middle- and upper-middle-class neighborhoods in this district that do rely on that credit. 

To Gallant’s credit, he did turn our story into allegations of his past into a fundraising haul and a new slogan – “Make Politics Sexy Again.” Credit where credit is due in turning a negative into a positive.

But we do think he’s being rather glib about it when transparency is far too out-of-reach in Washington. Moreover, that he didn’t seek to answer many of our questions, even those pertaining only to his campaign platform, gives us pause. 

Overall, we appreciate Gallant’s service to our country – his Black Hawk pilot status probably makes him the “coolest” Democrat to have run for this seat in recent memory – but he’s sticking to the safe talking points while not offering much else.

For LaLota, we respectfully urge the Congressman to be a bit more of a bipartisan maverick that he’s been in the past. He and the Long Island contingent are a valuable temperature check on what the suburbs need, and he and Congressman Garbarino and now-former Congressman D’Esposito effectively held up the Speaker of the House vote after Kevin McCarthy was ousted. They held out for Speaker Mike Johnson, whom they felt was much more sympathetic to Long Island’s needs.

Our point is this: the Long Island contingent has proven its power and worth. We hope they can voice some questions many of us have about the Iran War, government spending and equities, and transparency within all three branches of government. 

We know LaLota is outspoken and well-meaning. If Democrats end up taking control of the House, we think sending LaLota back to Congress keeps Long Island with the leg up. We don’t think Suffolk wants to start from scratch with a freshman Democrat, while the party overall will likely be on a revenge tour against Trump. 

The Messenger endorses LaLota.

Top Stories