Within the Town of Islip, the Eighth District includes Bayport, Bohemia, Great River, Islip Terrace, North Great River, Oak Beach, Oakdale, Saltaire, Sayville, and West Sayville, and parts of Bay Shore, Brightwaters, Captree-Oak Beach-Gilgo, East Islip, Holbrook, Holtsville, Islip hamlet, Ronkonkoma, West Bay Shore, and West Islip. The district also contains parts of the towns of Babylon and Oyster Bay.
Senator Alexis Weik, a Sayville Republican, is retiring after three terms. Voters have a great candidate to replace her in three-term Assemblyman Jarett Gandolfo.
Gandolfo, also a Republican of Sayville, has unique skin in the game. He’s under 40 and is raising two young children in perhaps one of the toughest economic climates seen in years. Make no mistake, Gandolfo is not in a bubble, and politics in general could use more people grounded in reality.
Gandolfo has an immense upper-hand in this contest as his Assembly seat overlaps much of this Senate district. He knows the landscape, the players, and the distinct needs of each hamlet. He’s been big on getting sewering done across the downtowns, and was staunchly vocal on the battlefield-like state of the Robert Moses Bridge.
Gandolfo has also been immeasurably valuable on holding the line on immigration. He’s sponsored, year after year, the Laken Riley Act to cut into New York’s Sanctuary policies and stem the flow of criminal migrants who could have been apprehended before going on to commit heinous acts. New York State, unfortunately, is not so commonsense on this issue, and we see Gandolfo as a respectable, dignified ambassador for what’s otherwise perhaps the most contentious issue of the political era.
Gandolfo faces first-time candidate Josh Taveras in this race. The Massapequa Democrat has a good heart and his backstory earns recognition for his tenacity, but he is unprepared for Albany. Taveras, clearly sympathetic to the Mamdani wing of the party, believes in “taxing billionaires” but offers no substantive plans. In fact, in our interview, he said his plans aren’t quite online yet. He’s also expressed interest in getting historically underserved school districts their fair share of dollars – a worthy cause and one we can endorse, but he provides no plan on how to accomplish that.
Taveras seems to take issue with how the local Republicans are running things; he points to that as the reason infrastructure projects lag. But with his vague engineering “background,” he said to us that while he’s not quite sure how the sewers and flooding problems on the South Shore work, he knows enough to know that what’s currently in place is not working. That’s not a good-faith attempt to galvanize the public that he’s the better man for the job.
Finally, Taveras puts a lot of stock into his identity. He said to us that his race and sexuality “check all the boxes,” and while we don’t take issue one way or the other – he’s entitled to his values – that’s not what gets the job done at the end of the day.
We find Taveras genuine in his concerns and wish him well on his personal endeavors, but we also find his candidacy unserious.
The Messenger endorses Gandolfo.












