Islip Democratic Candidate Violated NYS Public Finance Law with Latest Mailers

ISLIP – With Election Day just around the corner, a campaign for a Democratic candidate for an Islip-based State Senate seat issued mailers this week featuring endorsements of other political candidates at various offices after receiving funds from the State’s matching public funds program.

Josh Taveras (D-Massapequa) is making his first run for public office in the Eighth Senate District, which takes in most of the towns of Islip and Babylon and parts of the Town of Oyster Bay. The seat is being vacated by three-term Senator Alexis Weik (R-Sayville). Taveras faces three-term Assemblyman Jarett Gandolfo (R-Sayville) for the open seat on Tuesday.

The State’s matching funds program matches candidates’ individual contributions with public dollars on a multiplier. For every $1 a New York resident donates to a campaign, the State could add more. The more small donations a candidate receives from individual donors potentially unlocks more funds from the State.

Candidates must hit certain fundraising thresholds and hit certain expenditure thresholds in order to unlock matching funds.

The most recent State Board of Elections (BOE) filings show the Taveras campaign having received $127,259 in public funds, with $3,839.62 having stood as the qualified expenditures to receive funds.

Mailers that hit doors just this week, emblazoned with disclaimers that they were paid for by Friends of Josh Taveras, showing endorsements for fellow Democratic candidates for local office. Those include Pat Halpin (D-Oak Beach), who is running for New York’s Second Congressional District against Congressman Andrew Garbarino (R-Bayport), Taveras himself in his own race, Jon Estreich (D-Dix Hills), who is running for Suffolk County Comptroller, and Abigail Field (D-Cutchogue), the write-in candidate for Suffolk County Clerk.

Chapter 17, Article 4, Title 2 of New York State Law covers elections and campaign finance. Under Section 14-206(f), “a contribution or loan or transfer made to or expenditure to support another candidate or political committee” is prohibited. Section 14-206(g) prohibits and expenditure to “support or oppose a candidate for an office other than that which the participating candidate seeks.”

The aforementioned mailers are also negative in nature, with Taveras railing against his opponent, Assemblyman Gandolfo, as a MAGA-aligned Republican. The mailer criticizes the local Republican slate carte blanche: “They answer to Trump. We answer to you.”

The mailer negatively attacks Trump for endorsement of Congressman Garbarino, and alleges that Garbarino “handed” his Assembly seat to his then-chief of staff Gandolfo in 2020. The mailer also connects Gandolfo with Islip Town Councilwoman DawnMarie Kuhn (R-Bohemia), who is running for Gandolfo’s open Assembly seat. They take a quote dated October 26, 2025, of Gandolfo endorsing Kuhn.

They also took a Facebook post from Kuhn dated August 18, 2025, thanking EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin (R-Shirley) for “remaining true” to his “roots” after a press conference at the Hauppauge Fire Department regarding safety concerns around Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) Facilities.

Under New York State campaign finance law, these mailers violated the use of the matching funds. That the Taveras mailers positively cover Halpin and negatively cover Garbarino in the NY-02 race could gather the attention of the Federal Elections Commission (FEC). The treasurer for the the Taveras race is Kelly Perry (D-Bayport), who ran against Suffolk County Legislator Anthony Piccirillo (R-Holtsville) in 2025 after moving to the State just within a year prior.

Islip Democrats have been in turmoil the last few months as the Suffolk County Democratic Committee has been locked in a civil war over the future of their committee. The 26-year Chair of the Suffolk Democrats, Rich Schaffer (D-North Babylon), secured his re-election in September over progressive firebrand Kathryn Casey Quigley (D-Southold). Since then, Democratic committees in Brookhaven, Islip, and Huntington have been alleging top-down tricks from Schaffer to prevent dissidents from taking control of the town committees, as the delegates therein battle for their preferred vision of Suffolk’s future.

The evidence provided by the fliers calls into question how the public campaign system is monitored. The system is still being tested by the candidates as it was only unveiled in 2022.

The Messenger is awaiting comment from the Taveras campaign.

 

Top Stories