The Fifth District is split between the Towns of Brookhaven and Islip, containing the communities of Lake Grove, Holbrook, and parts of Bohemia, Centereach, Coram, Farmingville, Holbrook, Holtsville, Islandia, Lake Ronkonkoma, Medford, North Patchogue, Ronkonkoma, and Selden.
If there was an official mayor of Holbrook, we’d say that role belongs to Assemblyman Doug Smith.
Smith, a former teacher by trade, is perhaps one of Suffolk’s most valuable opinions on education, easily one of the most salient and contentious topics in New York over the last several years. The Holbrook Republican recently broke with party orthodoxy to endorse the end of Regents exam requirements for graduation, instead looking towards a more all-of-the-above approach.
While it might seem confusing to see a Republican in favor of education policy that’s generally seen as more of a Democratic cudgel, Smith brings a level of nuance to the issue that only stems from his deep Sachem roots.
“Not every kid wants to go to college,” Smith told our Editorial Board.
We’ve been arguing for a while now that the high school-to-college pipeline is not working for everyone. In fact, we’ll go as far as to say it’s a dying way of doing things in a world where the advertising for college is worth more than the degree most graduates earn. There must be alternatives, and Smith is acutely aware of that. We trust his judgement on this issue and appreciate his candidness.
Moreover, Smith has developed good relationships with those in the majority and has been able to make some hometown deliveries the last two years. In the heart of his district was the old Sachem administrative building. Holbrook’s Main Street is now short one blighted property and will soon be in reception of an all-accessible park that will likely double as a de facto village green.
Smith regularly expresses his desire to work more with the Governor, if only the Governor could make her prerogatives known, not just what seems electorally feasible.
Smith’s opponent, Holbrook Democrat Victoria Russell, is not actively campaigning.
The Messenger endorses Smith.












