Dave Weber for Assembly, District 12

Within the Town of Islip, the district contains parts of Brentwood, Baywood, North Bay Shore, and Pine Aire. Within the Town of Babylon, the district includes most of Deer Park. The district also contains the northern part of the Town of Huntington.

The Twelfth District is bidding farewell to three-term Assemblyman Keith Brown, leaving this competitive seat open this year. 

Voters have a good option in Northport Village Trustee Dave Weber. The Northport Republican has deep roots in the community, owning and operating a generational boatyard in the village’s harbor. 

Weber is attuned to environmental issues, the intricacies of the North Shore’s water ecology, and proper municipal planning. 

Weber faces Craig Herskowitz, a Democrat who also hails from Northport. This is his third consecutive run for public office. He first ran for State Senate in 2024 and then ran for County Legislature last year. 

Herskowitz has spent his time as an immigration attorney. He says the federal government’s enforcement is mismanaged and deliberately scary. Although he is correct that the buck ultimately stops with Congress, we think the State can stem the flow by undoing its Sanctuary policies. Herskowitz won’t go that far. 

Herskowitz said multiple times to us that he’s ready to bring back “hundreds of millions” of dollars into AD-12. That’s a worthy goal and one we’d like to see if he’s elected, but that’s an exorbitant sum for any district, let alone one represented by a freshman. WE think he’s setting himself up for failure, even if it is just campaign season hyperbole. 

Alarmingly, Herskowitz told us that Weber was fired as a Daytona Beach police officer for truancy. We obtained records from the department’s HR department that show Weber was terminated without prejudice and eligible for re-hire. 

Herskowitz’s smear of his opponent in this easily verifiable way, coupled with his “third time’s the charm” attempt for office makes him look opportunistic.

Weber is even-keeled and knows the ins and outs of local government. 

The Messenger endorses Weber.

Top Stories