HUNTINGTON – Newly released court filings detail the sexual harassment findings that led to the 2021 firing of a former Cuomo Administration lawyer who is now a Democratic candidate for the New York State Assembly.
Craig Herskowitz (D-Northport), a former assistant counsel to Governor Andrew Cuomo, was terminated in August 2021 after investigators substantiated allegations that his conduct toward a female colleague violated the state’s sexual harassment policy.
Herskowitz is now running for the state’s 12th Assembly District. In 2025, he ran for the Suffolk County Legislature, and in 2024, he ran for the state’s 2nd Senate District. During the latter campaign, he asserted to The Messenger that his termination was retaliation for helping with the investigation and for making a joke to a female coworker about the circumstances surrounding then-Governor Cuomo’s sexual harassment probe, which eventually led to Cuomo’s resignation in August 2021.
On October 26, 2026, the State Supreme Court sent the case back to the Court of Appeals for summary judgment, effectively determining whether Herskowitz was fired for sexual harassment or terminated in retaliation for cooperating in the case against his then-boss Cuomo.
The Claims
According to the records, Herskowitz, then 40, repeatedly asked the 24-year-old colleague for her telephone number, asked her on dates after she declined, discussed his dating and sex life with her, and stood at her desk for extended periods asking personal questions in a way that made her feel unable to leave. The report states he characterized these interactions as “witty banter.”
The report substantiated that during the week of July 26, 2021, Herskowitz offered to help speed up the Budget Director’s Approval (BDA) process for her transfer to the Department of Financial Services (DFS) if she gave him her phone number. Investigators noted that he first claimed she suggested the exchange and later called it a joke. Witnesses described it as him offering the favor after she had already refused to give him her number.
In his August 6, 2021, GOER interview, Herskowitz said he asked for her phone number “but not a date,” called it “more of a joke,” and claimed he once asked in a “professional capacity” because his executive assistant was out. In an August 10, 2021, email he admitted asking for her phone number “on more than one occasion.”
The deposition shows that Herskowitz was confronted by witnesses on offering to buy her a steak dinner in August 2020. Herskowitz said he “could have” made the comment but denied it was a date. In his deposition he stated, “That’s the only thing that I’m not clear on… I can definitely see myself jokingly say, ‘I’ll buy you a steak’… but I can say with 100% certainty I never would have taken her out on a steak dinner.”
Regarding discussions of his personal life, Herskowitz admitted pointing out that he was wearing the same suit as the day before because he had stayed at a woman’s house. He claimed the colleague initiated the conversation, asked to see a picture of the woman, and told him to “hit it and quit it.” He denied asking her about her romantic preferences or saying he had trouble finding someone who was not interested in his money. The report notes that when confronted about the length of time he spent at her desk, he claimed she was the one initiating contact.
On spending time at her desk, Herskowitz says he made a “conscious effort not to be at her desk for more than a minute,” later describing personal conversations and mutual confiding.
The report also includes an email from Herskowitz to his colleague, linking a $300 skydiving request to the phone number offer. He had not mentioned that in the interview.
These details come from the Draft Investigation Report of the Governor’s Office of Employee Relations and are obtainable through the state’s court system.
The report also names multiple coworkers who corroborated the harassment allegations against Herskowitz. Toyamim Rahman said that Herskowitz was “always going upstairs” to talk to the complainant and that he had seem him “trying to flirt” with her. He says Herskowitz asked her out multiple times, including offering her a steak dinner in front of a group in August 2020. He said the complainant had expressed discomfort to him.
The Coworkers
Winifer “Winnie” Estevez said she witnessed Herskowitz made persistent requests to the complainant “every chance he got.” She also witnessed the steak dinner invitation of August 2020 and called Herskowitz a “creeper.”
Estevez said she witnessed the complainant passing her cell phone around the office to show pictures on her Instagram profile. When Herskowitz took the phone, Estevez said in deposition, he began looking through her text messages, which made the complainant “extremely uncomfortable.” Later that day, Herskowitz called the complainant into his office, and not wanting to go alone, Estevez accompanied her. She says Herskowitz apologized and bought her flowers.
In his deposition, Herskowitz said Estevez had suggested her buy the complainant a bouquet of sunflowers, as they were the complainant’s favorite flowers. He said the complainant said, “Oh, that’s so sweet, I’m going to cry,” or words to that effect.
Mary Adelaja said the complainant told her that Herskowitz was “trying to sleep with her.”
These details come from the GOER Draft Investigation Report and related court filings in Herskowitz v. State of New York (Index No. 153247/2022).
“These documents were falsified by the Cuomo Administration and are evidence in my pending retaliation lawsuit,” Herskowitz told The Messenger via text. “They are publicly available because I initiated court proceedings that led to their release. The courts have already permitted my retaliation claim to move forward based on evidence.” He added that the falsified report was submitted by his attorney as evidence in his pending retaliation lawsuit.
The Timing
According to a March 2022 report by the Albany Times Union, Herskowitz had cooperated with investigators and corroborated allegations made by Charlotte Bennett, one of the women whose accusations helped precipitate Cuomo’s resignation.
Yet Herskowitz himself was facing allegations of inappropriate workplace conduct at the same time. The alleged conduct against Herskowitz began around August 2020 and continued into 2021.
On August 3, 2021, Attorney General Letitia James released her investigation into Cuomo’s sexual harassment of multiple women. That same day, Herskowitz made a remark to his female colleague that investigators later substantiated: “If the Governor didn’t sexually harass you, I don’t know why he bothered with anyone else.”
Cuomo’s special counsel and senior advisor, Beth Garvey, informed Herskowitz of his termination in August 2021. Herskowitz then alleged he was fired in retaliation. He claimed that his requests for the woman’s telephone number were work-related and that his termination was disproportionate.
State Supreme Court Justice Dakota D. Ramseur dismissed the entire complaint in January 2023. The Appellate Division, First Department, later revived only the retaliation claim, noting the temporal proximity between Herskowitz’s cooperation with the Attorney General’s investigation and his termination. After A.G. James’ release of the Cuomo investigation on August 3, 2021, the interviews with Rahman and Estevez began on August 5. Herskowitz’s interview took place August 6.
Herskowitz also contends that Post-It notes were left on desk his with taunting phrases, such as he “had it coming.”
The State has denied the retaliation allegations and maintains the termination was for legitimate, non-retaliatory reasons based on the substantiated findings of sexual harassment. Herskowitz has sought $4 million in damages plus fees and costs. The case remains pending on summary judgment.
“It is not news that Cuomo and his allies retaliated against me for cooperating with the A.G. investigation that substantiated the allegations of sexual harassment against him,” Herskowitz told The Messenger. “The document my opponent is circulating is one of numerous exhibits submitted by my own lawsuit. The Court has already allowed my retaliation claim to proceed based on the evidence presented.”
Herskowitz is the Democratic-Working Families candidate for New York’s 12th Assembly District in 2026. The district covers the northern part of Huntington, most of Deer Park, and parts of Baywood and North Bay Shore.












