Andrew Garbarino for U.S. House, NY-02

Garbarino HangerFest 2026

NY-02 contains the entire towns of Islip and Babylon, and parts of the Town of Oyster Bay. Within the Town of Brookhaven, NY-02 includes Bellport, Blue Point, Brookhaven hamlet, East Patchogue, Mastic, Mastic Beach, North Bellport, North Patchogue, Patchogue, Shirley, and parts of Farmingville, Holbrook, Holtsville, Medford, and Yaphank. 

Voters have two good candidates for this South Shore district. 

Congressman Andrew Garbarino has been on a glide path since his first election in 2020. The Republican, who hails from Bayport, was last summer handed the gavel on one of the House’s most powerful committees – Homeland Security. 

That says a lot about his seniority and the faith his colleagues have in him. Moreover, he’s been able to bring back tens of millions in funds for infrastructure and public safety projects across his district – Mastic Beach’s sewer district, West Islip’s sewer expansion, Bellport road improvements, Islip road improvements, and Brookhaven’s landfill capping project come to mind. 

Garbarino’s big win, besides securing funds for the 9/11 first responders health fund, is his collaboration with Congressman LaLota on quadrupling the SALT cap. The Suffolk duo set out in 2024 to lobby President Trump to reinstate the cap that Trump had eliminated in 2017. We applaud them for that successful effort. 

Garbarino faces a surprising opponent this year, former Suffolk County Executive Pat Halpin. The Oak Beach Democrat left elected office in the early 1990s, but remains active in Babylon Town development matters and just recently left the Suffolk County Water Authority as Chairman in 2022. 

Halpin has remained involved and our conversation with him was probably one of our favorites of this cycle. He is in tuned with the populist moods of this country and offers a more nuanced view of U.S. foreign policy that we can appreciate. 

Garbarino, however, is instilled in Congress, and that does likely translate to more funds down the road for needed projects and holding the suburban line for which we view Suffolk as the chief ambassador. The LaLota-Garbarino synergy is unmistakable, and we think to give up Garbarino’s standing in Congress at this point, especially with the House likely to flip blue, would be starting from scratch when Suffolk can’t afford to. 

We do, however, respectfully urge Garbarino to tap into that maverick energy that made him a pariah among South Shore conservatives not too long ago. We think the Trump Administration has not been beneficial this time around, particularly on the Iran War. Garbarino does get classified briefings, so we can defer there, but only to an extent insofar as the Administration continues to pitch this operation. 

Garbarino, along with the Suffolk delegation, has held up things before – and rightfully so. Their power and influence has been displayed. We’d like to see more of that. 

The Messenger endorses Garbarino.

Top Stories