The eighth Annual Civil War Christmas commenced this past weekend at St. John’s Church in Oakdale. The day concluded with a dessert contest, a performance by Idle Hour Elementary School Choir, and a Civil War Christmas Eve service in one of Long Island’s oldest and historically significant churches.
One of the highlights of the day was the Victorian-style dessert contest. This dessert contest was made inspired by 19th-century recipes and holiday traditions. The contest added a festive, interactive element to the day, underscoring the importance of holiday baking in the Civil War Era.
St. John’s Episcopal Church in Oakdale traces its roots to more than 250 years ago, with the present church building constructed by William Nicoll in 1765, a descendant of the Islip patentee. Originally known as “Charlotte Church,” named for Queen Charlotte of England, the structure predates the American Revolution and is believed to have been used by British troops as a barracks during the war.
Following the Revolution, the church was renamed St. John’s, reflecting the community’s shift away from its colonial ties. The historic churchyard surrounding the building contains graves dating back to the 18th century, offering a lasting connection to Oakdale’s earliest settlers. Today, St. John’s remains both an active place of worship and a cherished local landmark, listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Now bringing history back to life, the Oakdale Historical Society and community members transform a night back into the Civil War Era with this holiday celebration. The day concludes with a Christmas ceremony that reflects how the holiday was observed in the mid-19th century.
The ceremony includes Scripture, readings, and familiar carols. This service offers a glimpse into how faith and traditions persisted during the Civil War Era. Attendees participated by singing Christmas carols together, underscoring the event’s goal of honoring history and bringing the community together.
By blending history, faith, and community tradition, the annual Civil War Christmas at St. John’s Church offers a meaningful way to reflect on the season while honoring Oakdale’s past. As families gather beneath candlelight and period carols fill the historic sanctuary, the event serves as a reminder of the enduring power of tradition and the importance of preserving local history for future generations.
